Life, Liberty and the Death Penalty

This Thanksgiving, we give thanks for the freedom to worship, confess our faith, and share the hope of Christ with our neighbors. As you gather with family and friends to count the gifts Christ has given you, please consider supporting the Lutheran Center for Religious Liberty and its work to preserve these freedoms for future generations. Your prayers and generosity help ensure that Lutherans can continue to proclaim God’s truth faithfully and boldly. Help us protect this precious gift for the sake of Christ’s Church and the generations to come!

Some say that to be pro-life we must be consistent and be against the death penalty as well. Among rights endowed by our Creator are life and liberty. No government has the right to take our lives or incarcerate us without cause. But no right is absolute. I have the right to liberty, but if I commit a crime, I am no longer able to live freely. I may even, probably for a time, be put in prison, and for good reason. I may have the right to live freely, but then I do not have the right to steal someone else's goods, nor do I have a right to do them bodily injury. Because the other person has the right not to be beaten or stolen from, I forfeit my right to freedom and may be rightly placed in jail.

So also a person has a right to life. But then an active shooter may rightly be shot, be put down. By endangering the lives of others, he has forfeited his own right to life. Earthly justice is never perfect, though any just system should be congruent with natural law. Accordingly, there are levels of penalties depending on the crime. Homicide is treated differently from first degree murder. Crimes of passion are one thing, and premeditated murder is another. We might be prone to apply different sentences to a man who kills another while in a gang fight than we would a serial murderer or a murderer who preys upon children and employs sadistic torture in his modus operandi. And hanging would be appropriate, we might agree, for someone who sold our nuclear secrets or sent military plans to the enemy, thus putting whole armies and cities in jeopardy. Or consider the drug lord who has destroyed countless lives and will, if allowed to live, continue to run his operation behind bars.

The death penalty, justly administered and not as, say, a political tool, is an effective expression of our deepest pro-life concerns. Some murders are heinous, and justice cries out for the ultimate penalty.

But then what of those who speak about a penalty greater still? They say that we should not employ the death penalty, because that gives a person more time to repent. But consider the thief on the cross, who said, “We are put to death justly.” Christ did not deny the truth in the criminal's remarks. And that thief ended up being saved, as he repented and turned to Christ as his Savior.

It is not our business to make our earthly judgement a vehicle for salvation. We would not put to death a Christian, guilty or not, because we knew he was going to be fine and would wake up in the heavenly places. But neither should we eschew the death penalty at the hope of repentance. Historically, just application of the death penalty has included a timely call to repentance, to call a priest or minister, to make confession. We might say that the hangman’s noose served a purpose that may reflect the old adage that there is no such thing as an atheist in a foxhole. Whether it’s the battlefield or a dire diagnosis, knowledge of the end can be a bracing reminder that it is time to get our house in order.

What happens instead? A person receives 25 years to life and spends the rest of his life spinning his story, trying to manipulate the process, all the while living off a dime that includes the taxes of family members who have lost their loved ones to the one who acted in cold blood. As tax payers, they are paying the murderer's rent. And then, God forbid, they have to appear before parole boards on a semi-regular basis, thus reliving the trauma. And of course, the parole board is susceptible to false confessions, and the system benefits when it no longer has to house a criminal.

But then, let’s say a criminal repents and says, “I know I did wrong. But I am a changed man.” Ok, then why does not the man say, “I do not deserve to live. My life is an affront to justice, and a burden on the victim’s loved ones. I am ready to die.” If repentance is true, then well and good, and there is reason to rejoice. But repentance hardly takes away the earthly consequences of having killed one, or perhaps many people, possibly having treated them in the most sadistic, terrifying, and excruciatingly painful way.

Christ's forgiveness is for eternal life. The pastor willingly forgives the one who commits armed robbery or rape, but that person ought to go to jail nevertheless. And if the person is repentant, he, like the thief on the cross, will say, “I die justly.” He will feel the weight of the sin he has committed, and he will know that he cannot make things better, even as he knows that the Lord says to him, “Today you will be with me in paradise.”

If you want a truly pro-life culture, you cannot ignore justice, which goes hand in hand with our right to life. A little child, perhaps in the womb, should not be used as a pawn of comparison with brutal murderer. Such an equation takes no thought of justice. In the case of abortion, there is no justice for the innocent baby who has committed no crime. When capital punishment is taken off the table, there is no justice for the innocent people who have had their loved ones brutally, willfully, cruelly and unjustly put to death.

 

The Rev. Dr. Peter Scaer is chairman and professor of Exegetical Theology and director of the M.A. program at Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, Ind.

Be Informed
Lutherans are never afraid to stand—even march!—for life, and the Rev. Dr. Matthew C. Harrison invites you to join him in doing so at the 2027 National March for Life in Washington, D.C. Click here to learn more about how you can join together to defend life Friday, January 22, 2027.

Be Equipped
“We LCMS Lutherans are becoming well-trained in identifying and addressing the sins against human life that are utterly egregious,” Stephanie Neugebauer of LCMS Life Ministry explains.  “God be praised! The LCMS is unabashedly a pro-life church body. Yet Christians must keep vigilant, lest they fall prey to the same lies that secular culture has chewed on, swallowed and is still fueled by.” Read more about the lies the culture tells about life and how you can refute them close to home—with your friends and family who may believe them.

Be Encouraged
“Immanuel, God with us. How reassuring are those words?! The struggles of life, personally and professionally, often take us to the edge of an emotional cliff. Thankfully, there is One to whom we can reach out and call out for help. We are not alone—God is with us every step of the way in our personal and our professional lives.” –Gayle Irwin, Pregnancy Help News

Next
Next

Undoing the Damage to ‘Transitioned’ Children